
UPDATE November 16, 2026: Investigator and author Katie Carter @cartercarter26publicly accused filmmaker Lance Oppenheim @lanceopp – director of YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING – of stealing private “mitigation films”—short documentaries used by legal defense teams—and profiting from them. Just visit Katie Carter @cartercarter26 for the full details. *
According to Carter, the core details of the controversy include:
- The Alleged Incident: Carter states that Oppenheim attended a 2018 public defender training session under false pretenses, gained access to a password-protected Vimeo portfolio of private sentencing and mitigation videos, and downloaded the footage.
- The Project: Oppenheim allegedly used the stolen material to create the short documentary No Jail Time: The Movie, which he then sold and published through The New York Times.
- Real-World Impact: Carter claims the unapproved exposure exploited vulnerable defendants (including a client who was later executed), led to her mentor being fired, and forced the cancellation of national public defender trainings.
*So, factor all that in when you go to see YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING. I simply wasn’t aware of this until now and it does cast Nathan’s film in a new light. For folks who have actually taken the time to read the post that follows this update, thank you for reading. I welcome your feedback. I am not fully on board with the film. I think it’s very problematic. Either Nathan is extraordinarily gullible, which doesn’t seem likely, or he’s fine to do whatever it takes to create compelling content, which does sound about right. Anyway, that’s my update!
Nathan, I am so glad I went to see your documentary, You Can See Everything, your in-depth look at the last days of freedom, in 2023, for disgraced Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes. There are some film purists who decree that someone must not know anything about a film before going to see it, or should I say, “view” it, preferably not even know the title of the film. Well, I went in only knowing a certain amount about your body of work beforehand and, afterward, I took a deeper dive. So, maybe the best of both worlds? I already knew that you are the kind of person who will go to great lengths to ferret out the truth. I base this upon your last television program, The Rehearsal, where you have elaborate recreations of a person’s home and/or place of work, complete with a cast of extras, in order to have that person rehearse an upcoming pivotal moment in their life to as close to optimal perfection, going through as many potential outcomes as humanly possible. I never would have thought such an experiment was even an option outside of an off-the-books top secret government operation. But you were able to will this into existence. I think Elizabeth Holmes shares that extraordinarily high level of persistence and maybe that is what attracted you to making this documentary. Where there’s a will, there’s a way, right? As the show’s catch phrase goes, “Why leave life to chance?”

I’ll let you in on part of my process when I embark upon a movie review. Or should I be saying “film” review? I don’t think you mind which term I use. But those film purists/experts seem to mind. Okay, what I tend to do is find a way to hook into my next review. What I came up with for this one is what appeared to me to be the meeting of two very intense minds: you and Elizabeth. It seemed to me that both of you had met your match! That’s what I was thinking going into this. I just wonder what you might have been thinking going into this! You make a very candid remark early on in the film when you ask Elizabeth why she chose you to document her final days before heading off to prison. You insisted that you seemed to be an easy mark, someone not really able to readily refute what she had to say, perhaps as easily swayed by her charms as all the investors she defrauded with her phony invention. You are not a science guy, you told her. Why didn’t she go with a science guy? you asked her. And her response seemed to be sincere and disarming. Basically, she said she thought you’d be fair. Isn’t that the basic vibe? I think so. I know that it’s important not to get casual on these things. That’s the whole point of another early moment when this now infamous interview with The New York Times comes up. The reporter in question didn’t see your point in all this is what seems to be going on.

So, what happened there with this interview with The New York Times? Well, Elizabeth and her husband, Billy Evans, who is quite a handful but we’ll come back to that, are discussing an article in which a reporter quotes Elizabeth as having said that she created a character during her time at the helm of Theranos. The quote goes, “A character that I created.” But, Billy and Elizabeth emphatically state this is not something Elizabeth would ever have said. At best, it would have been along the lines of referring to what the media had conjured up, a remark like: “A character that they created.” So, a simple argument it would seem. Both Billy and Elizabeth were quick to point out that the Times reporter has never provided any proof of this quote and the Times backs her up. The point of all this is that the quote seems to be very telling. One version has Elizabeth appearing to explicitly admit to creating a character, therefore perhaps revealing the potential for a web of lies. The other version is just an innocuous observation: actors in movies and TV were creating a character of her. Nathan, you saw the significance to this and ran with it.

Why a reporter for The New York Times would prefer not to chat with you at length on camera is, well, very interesting to say the least. But it gets more interesting! There’s always time to let the dust settle. In this case, that reporter, Amy Chozick, who is nowhere to be found on camera, although willing to talk a bit off camera during the filming of this documentary, chose to finally make herself more fully available with her own essay on October 30, 2026, stating her side of the story that was published on her former employer’s website. You can be the judge but her essay sure sounds, what’s the best way to say it, dismissive of you? Chozick has no problem painting you, Nathan, in a negative light. She tries to play nice by wishing you well at the Oscars. All in all, Chozick blames the controversy on the over-specific era we live in. There is the one thing that I can see now as titling in favor of Chozick and completely rings true. The idea of Holmes creating a character is at the heart of the brand she created for herself, isn’t it? She maintained this deep-voiced version of herself, along with wearing the Steve Jobs turtleneck sweaters, in order, in her mind, to be taken more seriously. Well, Chozick certainly has a point, you have to admit. Still, it could have been interesting to have her chat with you on camera but, as you well know from your own experiences on your TV shows, you can’t always have your way.

I think I have a neat solution for you, even though it is now impossible to include in your documentary, unless you were to go back and add this, which I guess I wouldn’t be surprised if you did! There’s always director’s cut special editions of this film or that film. Since you already do a lot of high concept stuff, like these elaborate recreations, here’s some material just waiting for you to put to use. The New York Times, bless their souls, sort of took a page out of your playbook. In a segment they call, The Backstory, dated October 26, 2026, they went back to try to connect the dots regarding the Holmes quote. This is what Chozick had to say on what Holmes actually said regarding creating her character:
“It was six weeks before Holmes went to prison for fraud. Evans had gone to the gym, and Holmes and I walked their dog, Teddy, on the beach outside their Del Mar, Calif., rental home. I was taking notes in my reporter’s notebook. At that point, we’d already spent several days together and talked extensively about the persona she’d adopted as the chief executive of Theranos. We talked about why she made her voice deeper and wore black turtlenecks and red lipstick, so it was an extension of that conversation.
As we walked, I told Holmes that I heard Jennifer Lawrence had recently pulled out of portraying her in a movie. She looked over at me, and said: “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created.” As she walked a couple of steps ahead, I wrote down her exact words in my notebook.
Every night when I’ve been out reporting, I go through my notebook and put a star next to anything I think is a particularly important moment or quote and I highlight it and flag that page with a Post-it note. This quote was highlighted and the page had a Post-it.
A lot of people’s most honest, on-the-record reflections come when I turn off my recorder and just take notes. I wasn’t going to put a recorder in Holmes’s face as we walked on the beach. I take notes constantly, to jot down important quotes and details and to incorporate my impressions in real time. I generally keep my reporter’s notebooks for a couple of years before getting rid of them. My editors confirmed the quote with me in 2023, and I thought the matter was resolved. I didn’t anticipate that the quote would become a part of a documentary years later. Of course, now I really wish I’d kept that notebook.
In “You Can See Everything,” Evans says he recorded all of our conversations, but this is not accurate. I spent several days with Holmes and Evans, always on the record. We did several formal interviews at the kitchen table and on the couch when we both recorded the conversations. But a lot of the most revealing moments came when the recorders were turned off. For example, when they were loading the babies into the Tesla or when we went to the San Diego Zoo and got tacos at the Lucha Libre Taco Shop in Mission Hills. I wrote down quotes and details as the conversations unfolded.”
The host of The Backstory column asks Chozick why people should believe her and she says:
“It’s a fair question. Holmes and I talked extensively about the character she created at Theranos, which she says her romantic and business partner, Sunny Balwani, pressured her to adopt. In the profile, this is what follows “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created”:
So, why did she create that public persona? “I believed it would be how I would be good at business and taken seriously and not taken as a little girl or a girl who didn’t have good technical ideas,” said Ms. Holmes, who founded Theranos at 19. “Maybe people picked up on that not being authentic, since it wasn’t.”
Those additional quotes and context were never disputed. Holmes told me repeatedly how Balwani encouraged her to “kill Elizabeth” — to wear black turtlenecks, to not talk like a “little girl,” to drink green juice, go vegan, not sleep for more than five hours, etc. (Balwani’s lawyer denied this, when we spoke.) Hollywood screenwriters didn’t invent the black turtlenecks, the deep voice or the red lipstick.
My late mentor, David Carr, used to say writing a profile is like holding a mirror up to a person. They don’t always like what they see. I’ve profiled some of the most controversial figures of our time, and I am always surprised by which details or quotes strike a nerve with them. But this one stood out to me because Holmes spoke openly, over several days, about the persona she created at Theranos. This was the first interview she had given since the blood-testing company imploded, and she looked and sounded like a completely different person from the public figure people remembered. How and why she’d created that persona was a topic that we returned to repeatedly.”
Well, Nathan, I found your documentary to be incredibly fascinating since you have these two, Elizabeth and Billy, going back and forth in real time. There is much to marvel over in regards to the exchanges you get with them and from them. But, to be fair, I am also quite impressed with reading Amy Chozick’s reporter’s notes, which come across as very impressive and professional. I’m grateful to have you both, your brilliant film and Amy Chozick’s equally brilliant writing.

So, shortly after seeing your film, I binge-watched all of The Rehearsal and your previous show, the prankster-comedy, Nathan For You. And I was struck by how much you’ve grown as an artist. I can see that you want to evolve and learn from your mistakes. The last episode of Nathan For You, in my opinion, is a summation of what you’d learned from doing a show that was heavy on comedy and slim on substance. “Finding Frances” is a step into greater things. And now, here you are, all the closer to truly being able to see everything.























































