Tag Archives: Movies

Open Letter to  Nathan Fielder: Bravo, You Can See Everything!

UPDATE November 16, 2026: Investigator and author Katie Carter @cartercarter26 publicly accused filmmaker Lance Oppenheim @lanceopp – director of YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING – of stealing private “mitigation films”—short documentaries used by legal defense teams—and profiting from them. Just visit Katie Carter @cartercarter26 for the full details.
*
According to Carter, the core details of the controversy include:
  • The Alleged Incident: Carter states that Oppenheim attended a 2018 public defender training session under false pretenses, gained access to a password-protected Vimeo portfolio of private sentencing and mitigation videos, and downloaded the footage.
  • The Project: Oppenheim allegedly used the stolen material to create the short documentary No Jail Time: The Movie, which he then sold and published through The New York Times.
  • Real-World Impact: Carter claims the unapproved exposure exploited vulnerable defendants (including a client who was later executed), led to her mentor being fired, and forced the cancellation of national public defender trainings.
*
So, factor all that in when you go to see YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING. I simply wasn’t aware of this until now and it does cast Nathan’s film in a new light. For folks who have actually taken the time to read the post that follows this update, thank you for reading. I welcome your feedback. I am not fully on board with the film. I think it’s very problematic. Either Nathan is extraordinarily gullible, which doesn’t seem likely, or he’s fine to do whatever it takes to create compelling content, which does sound about right. Anyway, that’s my update!

Nathan, I am so glad I went to see your documentary, You Can See Everything, your in-depth look at the last days of freedom, in 2023, for disgraced Theranos CEO Elizabeth Holmes. There are some film purists who decree that someone must not know anything about a film before going to see it, or should I say, “view” it, preferably not even know the title of the film. Well, I went in only knowing a certain amount about your body of work beforehand and, afterward, I took a deeper dive. So, maybe the best of both worlds? I already knew that you are the kind of person who will go to great lengths to ferret out the truth. I base this upon your last television program, The Rehearsal, where you have elaborate recreations of a person’s home and/or place of work, complete with a cast of extras, in order to have that person rehearse an upcoming pivotal moment in their life to as close to optimal perfection, going through as many potential outcomes as humanly possible. I never would have thought such an experiment was even an option outside of an off-the-books top secret government operation. But you were able to will this into existence. I think Elizabeth Holmes shares that extraordinarily high level of persistence and maybe that is what attracted you to making this documentary. Where there’s a will, there’s a way, right? As the show’s catch phrase goes, “Why leave life to chance?”

I’ll let you in on part of my process when I embark upon a movie review. Or should I be saying “film” review? I don’t think you mind which term I use. But those film purists/experts seem to mind. Okay, what I tend to do is find a way to hook into my next review. What I came up with for this one is what appeared to me to be the meeting of two very intense minds: you and Elizabeth. It seemed to me that both of you had met your match! That’s what I was thinking going into this. I just wonder what you might have been thinking going into this! You make a very candid remark early on in the film when you ask Elizabeth why she chose you to document her final days before heading off to prison. You insisted that you seemed to be an easy mark, someone not really able to readily refute what she had to say, perhaps as easily swayed by her charms as all the investors she defrauded with her phony invention. You are not a science guy, you told her. Why didn’t she go with a science guy? you asked her. And her response seemed to be sincere and disarming. Basically, she said she thought you’d be fair. Isn’t that the basic vibe? I think so. I know that it’s important not to get casual on these things. That’s the whole point of another early moment when this now infamous interview with The New York Times comes up. The reporter in question didn’t see your point in all this is what seems to be going on.

So, what happened there with this interview with The New York Times? Well, Elizabeth and her husband, Billy Evans, who is quite a handful but we’ll come back to that, are discussing an article in which a reporter quotes Elizabeth as having said that she created a character during her time at the helm of Theranos. The quote goes, “A character that I created.” But, Billy and Elizabeth emphatically state this is not something Elizabeth would ever have said. At best, it would have been along the lines of referring to what the media had conjured up, a remark like: “A character that they created.” So, a simple argument it would seem. Both Billy and Elizabeth were quick to point out that the Times reporter has never provided any proof of this quote and the Times backs her up. The point of all this is that the quote seems to be very telling. One version has Elizabeth appearing to explicitly admit to creating a character, therefore perhaps revealing the potential for a web of lies. The other version is just an innocuous observation: actors in movies and TV were creating a character of her. Nathan, you saw the significance to this and ran with it.

Why a reporter for The New York Times would prefer not to chat with you at length on camera is, well, very interesting to say the least. But it gets more interesting! There’s always time to let the dust settle. In this case, that reporter, Amy Chozick, who is nowhere to be found on camera, although willing to talk a bit off camera during the filming of this documentary, chose to finally make herself more fully available with her own essay on October 30, 2026, stating her side of the story that was published on her former employer’s website. You can be the judge but her essay sure sounds, what’s the best way to say it, dismissive of you? Chozick has no problem painting you, Nathan, in a negative light. She tries to play nice by wishing you well at the Oscars. All in all, Chozick blames the controversy on the over-specific era we live in. There is the one thing that I can see now as titling in favor of Chozick and completely rings true. The idea of Holmes creating a character is at the heart of the brand she created for herself, isn’t it? She maintained this deep-voiced version of herself, along with wearing the Steve Jobs turtleneck sweaters, in order, in her mind, to be taken more seriously. Well, Chozick certainly has a point, you have to admit. Still, it could have been interesting to have her chat with you on camera but, as you well know from your own experiences on your TV shows, you can’t always have your way.

I think I have a neat solution for you, even though it is now impossible to include in your documentary, unless you were to go back and add this, which I guess I wouldn’t be surprised if you did! There’s always director’s cut special editions of this film or that film. Since you already do a lot of high concept stuff, like these elaborate recreations, here’s some material just waiting for you to put to use. The New York Times, bless their souls, sort of took a page out of your playbook. In a segment they call, The Backstory, dated October 26, 2026, they went back to try to connect the dots regarding the Holmes quote. This is what Chozick had to say on what Holmes actually said regarding creating her character:

“It was six weeks before Holmes went to prison for fraud. Evans had gone to the gym, and Holmes and I walked their dog, Teddy, on the beach outside their Del Mar, Calif., rental home. I was taking notes in my reporter’s notebook. At that point, we’d already spent several days together and talked extensively about the persona she’d adopted as the chief executive of Theranos. We talked about why she made her voice deeper and wore black turtlenecks and red lipstick, so it was an extension of that conversation.

As we walked, I told Holmes that I heard Jennifer Lawrence had recently pulled out of portraying her in a movie. She looked over at me, and said: “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created.” As she walked a couple of steps ahead, I wrote down her exact words in my notebook.

Every night when I’ve been out reporting, I go through my notebook and put a star next to anything I think is a particularly important moment or quote and I highlight it and flag that page with a Post-it note. This quote was highlighted and the page had a Post-it.

A lot of people’s most honest, on-the-record reflections come when I turn off my recorder and just take notes. I wasn’t going to put a recorder in Holmes’s face as we walked on the beach. I take notes constantly, to jot down important quotes and details and to incorporate my impressions in real time. I generally keep my reporter’s notebooks for a couple of years before getting rid of them. My editors confirmed the quote with me in 2023, and I thought the matter was resolved. I didn’t anticipate that the quote would become a part of a documentary years later. Of course, now I really wish I’d kept that notebook.

In “You Can See Everything,” Evans says he recorded all of our conversations, but this is not accurate. I spent several days with Holmes and Evans, always on the record. We did several formal interviews at the kitchen table and on the couch when we both recorded the conversations. But a lot of the most revealing moments came when the recorders were turned off. For example, when they were loading the babies into the Tesla or when we went to the San Diego Zoo and got tacos at the Lucha Libre Taco Shop in Mission Hills. I wrote down quotes and details as the conversations unfolded.”

The host of The Backstory column asks Chozick why people should believe her and she says:

“It’s a fair question. Holmes and I talked extensively about the character she created at Theranos, which she says her romantic and business partner, Sunny Balwani, pressured her to adopt. In the profile, this is what follows “They’re not playing me. They’re playing a character I created”:

So, why did she create that public persona? “I believed it would be how I would be good at business and taken seriously and not taken as a little girl or a girl who didn’t have good technical ideas,” said Ms. Holmes, who founded Theranos at 19. “Maybe people picked up on that not being authentic, since it wasn’t.”

Those additional quotes and context were never disputed. Holmes told me repeatedly how Balwani encouraged her to “kill Elizabeth” — to wear black turtlenecks, to not talk like a “little girl,” to drink green juice, go vegan, not sleep for more than five hours, etc. (Balwani’s lawyer denied this, when we spoke.) Hollywood screenwriters didn’t invent the black turtlenecks, the deep voice or the red lipstick.

My late mentor, David Carr, used to say writing a profile is like holding a mirror up to a person. They don’t always like what they see. I’ve profiled some of the most controversial figures of our time, and I am always surprised by which details or quotes strike a nerve with them. But this one stood out to me because Holmes spoke openly, over several days, about the persona she created at Theranos. This was the first interview she had given since the blood-testing company imploded, and she looked and sounded like a completely different person from the public figure people remembered. How and why she’d created that persona was a topic that we returned to repeatedly.”

Well, Nathan, I found your documentary to be incredibly fascinating since you have these two, Elizabeth and Billy, going back and forth in real time. There is much to marvel over in regards to the exchanges you get with them and from them. But, to be fair, I am also quite impressed with reading Amy Chozick’s reporter’s notes, which come across as very impressive and professional. I’m grateful to have you both, your brilliant film and Amy Chozick’s equally brilliant writing.

So, shortly after seeing your film, I binge-watched all of The Rehearsal and your previous show, the prankster-comedy, Nathan For You. And I was struck by how much you’ve grown as an artist. I can see that you want to evolve and learn from your mistakes. The last episode of Nathan For You, in my opinion, is a summation of what you’d learned from doing a show that was heavy on comedy and slim on substance. “Finding Frances” is a step into greater things. And now, here you are, all the closer to truly being able to see everything.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Movie Reviews

So Buttons #15 by Jonathan Baylis comics review

So Buttons #15. w. Jonathan Baylis. various artists. Alchemy Comics.  36pp. $10.

And so the saga continues. We’re up to Issue 15 in the life and times of one Jonathan Baylis: stories, anecdotes and observations he writes and then various talented comics artists illustrate. As was the case with the great comics trailblazer Harvey Pekar, who was known for relentlessly recounting all aspects of his life, drilling down to all manner of minutiae, so Baylis gives readers his take on things.

The stylings of Jonathan Baylis and Danny Hellman.

These comics are a nice snackable size, a nod to one of the go-to mini-comic formats, the folded copier paper size of 8.5 x 5.5. You can easily travel with it and maybe read it on the train, a bus station or airport. I had it with me in my bag so I sat down at a fairly nice waystation on my journey. I had remembered enjoying a quaint spot at the airport food court and chose to eat my food at an expansive space owned by another restaurant chain. I was not shooed away. Maybe it was because I ordered a beer from them. Or maybe they noticed I was reading So Buttons and knew to leave me alone.

The stylings of Jonathan Baylis and Kari Christian Krumpholz.

The waitress made the right choice to allow me to proceed unhindered. In fact, I was honored. I couldn’t help but notice other people would attempt to do just as I did, bring food from one fine establishment and sit down and use the long luxurious table from another establishment. The waitress would swoop down and reprimand these folks: “This is a restaurant. I’m sorry but you can’t eat here.” Perhaps, if these fine folk had been given a chance to order something, all would have been forgiven. Perhaps if these fine folk were reading So Buttons, like I was, they would have been given a friendly nod and welcomed. Alas, I was favored; they were not.

The stylings of Jonathan Baylis and Bhanu Pratap.

Well, I’ve gotta say that Baylis is groovin’ on what he’s doin’. Based upon my reading his last issue and what he says about his own writing process, involving lively free association and leaping from one subject to another, I think Harvey Pekar would be amused and proud. Put ‘er there friend, you’re a gritty authentic son of a gun.

The stylings of Jonathan Baylis and Noah Van Sciver.

One hightlight that is particularly spot on is the pairing of Baylis with noted humorist and cartoonist Noah Van Sciver. Given the subject of family dynamics, especially dissecting one’s father, this amounts to a dream team combination.

The stylings of Jonathan Baylis and Nathan Gelgud.

Another highlight that’s really on the money is the paring of Baylis with cinephile -activist-cartoonist Nathan Gelgud. The idea here is that film is too precious and vital to only be shared among a select few. Indeed. Power to the People!

2 Comments

Filed under Comics, Comics Reviews

Nathan Gelgud cartoonist interview

Nathan Gelgud

If you’re in L.A., be sure to participate in a comics workshop led by Nathan Gelgud on February 12, 2026. Sometimes, the last mentions need to go first. Seriously, this is an opportunity to learn the process of making comics from a very thoughtful and dedicated cartoonist. Gelgud is known for his comics about cinema and culture, published by The New York Times. His new book, Reel Politik, published by Drawn & Quarterly, is a collection of his hilarious comic strip about a bunch of art house movie theater employees who become revolutionaries. I got to chat with Nathan and get a better appreciation for his comic strip and his point of view.

Nathan Gelgud is someone who loves movies, all kinds of movies. He has studied film theory and history and viewed countless films. Along the way, he decided that a great way to express and share his passion is through comics. If you’re still unsure of what this is all about, think of it this way: the comics medium allows Gelgud to create work that explains things that often are only discussed in academic circles or within groups of film enthusiasts. He opens things up for everyone.

The idea of making things accessible for all the people is a big theme here. As I got to know Nathan’s comic strip, and then chat with him, I got a better appreciation for the man and his work. You can read my initial thoughts on Reel Politik in my review here. While preparing for my interview, I revisited the comic strip and delved deeper, getting to know the characters: Skip, the manager of the movie theater before it was taken over and turned into the people’s theater; Sandra, the slouch with supernatural powers; Bertie, the diehard revolutionary; and Hale, who prefers to sit on the fence until further notice. Perhaps I’m a little bit like Hale, open to new challenges but not always certain how to proceed. I suppose we’re all a little bit like Hale.

It was a pleasure to chat with Nathan. I know we could have covered even more and I feel like we get along. Hopefully, we’ll have him back. For now, enjoy this interview!

And remember, if you’re in the L.A. area, go to the Scribble event:

How To Make Comics

Thursday, Feb 12, 2026, 6:00 PM

How To Make Comics: A Workshop with Nathan Gelgud (New York Times, New Yorker, Hyperallergic, The Paris Review, Reel Politik).

– Make a one page comic

– Talk about being a working cartoonist

– Kill your inner critic

 

Guided workshop from 6-8pm

All are welcome to stick around for additional discussion and drawing until 9pm!

 

All levels welcome!

Materials provided

 

RSVP here, pay what you want at the door (no one will be turned away)

Arrive late and leave early!

EDITOR’S NOTE: This workshop is ongoing. Note that the next one is online and, as of this writing, is coming up on February 19th. Register by emailing Nathan! Find him at his website.

1 Comment

Filed under Comics, Interviews

☀️ REEL POLITIK | comics review 💬

Review by Henry Chamberlain

Reel Politik. Nathan Gelgud. Drawn & Quarterly. 2025. 172pp. $20.

When you’re a young artist, with more ideals than money, your day job a prime indicator (barista, bookseller, movie usher), you know what you’re in for: your life is full of like-minded souls; and, heck, maybe you’ll get caught up in some clumsy attempts at overthrowing capitalism. That’s the vibe to Reel Politik, the hilarious comic strip by Nathan Gelgud, about a ragtag group of employees hanging on by their fingernails at a local indie movie theater. You can catch up with the latest post on Gelgud’s Instagram and you can enjoy a new collection published by Drawn & Quarterly.

Gelgud’s comics about movies, and the arts in general, appear in The New York Times, The New Yorker and The New York Review of Books. This new book of his Reel Politik comic strip gives you a handy and fun way to jump right into it all. You’re getting a special view of the whole moviegoer scene from someone who’s tracked it from various vantage points: projectionist, video store clerk, movie critic and, of course, as a cartoonist.

When you’re young, just starting out, you’ve got a whole plethora of defense mechanisms. The go-to shield for all manner of artists, from poseurs to die-hard bohemians, is to take on the role of an expert. Sometimes this works out really well, especially if you’ve actually read the book or viewed the movie you’re pontificating about–or maybe you’ve at least listened to a podcast on the subject at hand? Ah, standards have plummeted under the guise of being mired in privilege. Anyway, Gelgud provides delicious portraits of various cinema/activist purists among his characters such as Sandra, who believes a pure cinema experience includes going to a movie theater without knowing what film you’re about to view. This is not just a quirky philosophy for her but something she imposes upon her innocent customers.

A really good comic strip takes on a life of its own and is open to various interpretations. Gelgud, in the tradition of great cartoonists, is a keen social observer, ready to poke fun at the culture-at-large and its critics. A case in point is well into the narrative, once the movie employees have taken over and freed cinema of its capitalist shackles. Sandra is rejoicing over how cinema is now free and For The People. No one is enslaved to the strictures of the past–the hierarchy imposed by the Criterion Collection. Someone points out a man who has been put in a cage. Sandra shrugs and admits some people are less equal than others. The man in the cage is serving time for having scratched a copy of a beloved classic film! We’ve been brainwashed by a consumer culture but we’ve also been brainwashed by a slogan-heavy activist class.

Well, the politics in Reel Politik never gets too heavy. If you can’t take a joke, then maybe you’re part of the problem, no? Overall, this is a comic strip full of whimsical humor, biting satire and guided by a true love for a couple of often misunderstood art forms: cinema and comics!

1 Comment

Filed under Comics, Comics Reviews

Superman, Apple Pie and MAGA

It’s been a minute since we had a full-on Superman major motion picture with all the trimmings. And this new installment shows with each charming but self-conscious step. It’s like a very expensive and fragile antique has been brought down from wherever it usually hides and one hopes it survives the special occasion that summoned it from its crypt. Superman is like that. Also like the James Bond franchise. Just as you’re getting used to one Bond, they bring in a new model. What was wrong with Henry Cavill? He seems to have a lot of mileage ahead of him. Well, he’s 42. The new guy, David Corenswet, is ten years younger. But there’s no getting around the fact that the actual character goes back to 1938. And, some will argue, Christopher Reeve, in the role of Superman, along with Margot Kidder as Lois Lane, in 1978, will always be the gold standard. In fact, Corenswet seems to be channeling Reeve in a pretty big way. The same with the new Lois, played by 34-year-old Rachel Brosnahan. There’s no doubt that the producers were looking for a certain je ne sais quoi and Brosnahan has that world-weary Kidder vibe down. The script doesn’t bother with formalities with these two and has them all over each other back at Lois’s apartment within a few minutes after the first big action scene. They are so used to each other after dating a couple of months that they let loose with a mildly tense quarrel. It was something else. It made a baby cry in the movie theater I was at.

Now, some talking heads have made a big deal about Superman updating for the age of MAGA. And I think the producers tried to split things down the middle. They gave Clark Kent a new set of parents cut from a MAGA trope: more of a laid-back Southern flavor as opposed to a prim and uptight Midwestern reserve that was the original recipe. Clark was raised in Smallville, Kansas after all, not West Virginia. Anyway, that part is done with kindness. The other part could be hard for some hardcore Trump fans to swallow and that’s stuff like Superman duking it out with Lex Luthor with Superman saying things like, “Yeah, I’m an alien and I’m proud of it. I’m a real person.” and Luthor saying, “I don’t care. The government has given me permission to do whatever I want with you!” Your mileage will vary. You can’t avoid a little sprinkle of politics when you’re dealing with such a colossal cultural figure as Superman. Director James Gunn referred to Superman as an embattled immigrant and that alone has created a bit of a firestorm. Every era has its own Superman and so it goes.

But getting back to the whole idea of a major Superman movie. It does feel like the good china and silverware is being brought out. My harshest view would be that the whole thing feels as if its been embalmed in formaldehyde, lost somewhere in the mist of the 1930s up to the 1970s. Maybe that’s a good thing, the fact that this sort of thing is still being done. It’s a very expensive experiment in entertainment but I can only imagine no one is going to lose their shirt over this. It’s going to appeal to a lot of people but that just goes with the brand. It’s too tempting for too many people. And I think it’s mostly going to be older people too even though efforts are made to make these characters seem youthful. One clue to the tilt toward older viewers, I think, is how Lois and Clark are supposed to be such huge fans of punk music. The way they carry on about their devotion to the punk ethos makes them sound more like people twenty or so years older than themselves. And that makes sense given that 58-year-old James Gunn is the movie’s writer and director. But good for him! I think the love for a beloved subject carries over into one’s life in more ways than one. I’m good with that.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Movie Reviews, Superman

Cartoon Art Museum in San Francisco: George’s Run author Henry Chamberlain 08/24/2025

I have an event coming up at San Francisco’s Cartoon Art Museum, 781 Beach Street, on Sunday, August 24th, 2-4pm to talk about my graphic narrative, George’s Run: A Writer’s Journey Through The Twilight Zone, published by Rutgers University Press. It would be so great to have you there if possible.

If you are a science fiction fan, or love various forms of related genres, this is for you. Science fiction acts as a convenient umbrella but, if I was asked to dig deeper in my description, it would be Dark Fantasy. My book is about a group of writers who, individually and in their combined efforts, basically invented a lot of the pop culture we take for granted today. Specifically, I’m talking about the writers behind the original Twilight Zone and Star Trek.

We’ll have a slide show lecture format where I’ll share as much as I can about how I went about creating my book. George Clayton Johnson is our guide, one of the last writers from that 1950s-70s era of golden age television writing. I got to know George pretty well and our friendship led to my book. We’ll have plenty of time for a Q&A as well as overall discussion. I’ll take my cue from the audience. I’m happy to do demonstrations of my art style and chat about making comics too. Feel free to draw or write along the way, and we can share results after we’ve had time to discuss. Hey, this is as open-ended as you like. We might even have some snacks. Seriously, comment here or get a hold of me via email and I’ll consider any ideas.

One step at a time. First, let’s plan on meeting up at the Cartoon Art Museum on August 24th.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, George Clayton Johnson, Henry Chamberlain

Pop Culture Bits: George Lucas, Star Wars and Summer

I happened to be in San Francisco recently and found myself doing what has become a ritual for many Star Wars fans: the big visit to see the tech campus that houses the Lucasfilm headquarters in San Francisco, located within the Letterman Digital Arts Center nestled within the Presidio. If you go, it might be a bit of a downer, more of a subdued pilgrimage since you’re only going to get to see the campus (which is, no doubt, beautiful) and then loiter around the reception lobby. There’s a fair amount of movie memorabilia to view but, it’s basically a work place so don’t expect to see your favorite characters ready to pose for photos. I’d be curious to know if any of my readers have made this visit and what you thought. I went in with no expectations or maybe I assumed the space was more lived-in, part of an actual communal library for employees. It’s not. It’s mostly a place to pick up your food delivery, and assorted business, just like any other office.

Amid books and Star Wars figures.

Sadly, I discovered that the library was basically fake. Many of the books are only props: real enough books but only a certain amount that you could call relevant. For instance, there’s a copy of the novel, An Affair to Remember, which was adapted into the 1957 film starring Cary Grant and Deborah Kerr. Okay, that’s definitely movie-related but not really something you’d expect Darth Vader to be reading, am I right? How about another title on these shelves: An Only Child, by Frank O’Conor? I guess that sort of echoes the childhood of Luke Skywalker but that’s a bit of a stretch. Then there’s Pop Culture Mania, by Stephen Hughes: a guidebook on how to collect various items of pop culture ephemera. Closer but not exactly satisfying. But, hey, I’m just being silly, I suppose. That said, I can only imagine there might be some kind of corporate library somewhere beyond the reception lobby. If you happen to work at Lucasfilm, please let me know if you have such a library! Just wondering!

Nevil Shute finds a home in the reception lobby library.

Perhaps the best looking match-up of books on display with curio in the lobby is this combination: A “bust” of a Star Wars storm trooper and a collection of the works of Nevil Shute, a notable science fiction writer. His best-selling novel, On the Beach, first published in 1957, is an all-time classic work of post-apocalyptic science fiction.

It’s the beginning of summer. I’m in San Francisco. George Lucas and Star Wars loom over me. I’m ready to see a Sci-Fi blockbuster! Is one fast approaching? I did overhear some heated conversation on the topic but no industry secrets were revealed, just idle conversation. If you want upcoming attraction news, you can go over here and you’ll be hip to Ryan Gosling set to appear in the next major Star Wars movie in 2027! At one time, Gosling was set to appear in the sequel to the 1976 Sci-Fi cult classic, Logan’s Run but that did not take hold. I believe everything did take hold for Star Wars. So, all’s well that ends well and Nevil Shute finds a welcome home in the reception lobby library of Lucasfilm HQ in SF.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Star Wars

DEAD AIR: The Night That Orson Welles Terrified America book review

Dead Air: The Night That Orson Welles Terrified America. William Elliott Hazelgrove. Rowman & Littlefield. 2024. 280pp. $32.

For six seconds, Orson Welles held his audience in suspense with utter silence during the infamous 1938 Halloween broadcast of The War of the Worlds. This is the linchpin moment vital to this book’s argument that Orson Welles had a malevolent intention behind this most talked about radio scare. Was it a playful prank, an attempt at art, that got out of control? Most will argue that to be the case. William Elliott Hazelgrove, the author of this book, prefers to paint a much darker picture. Whatever the case, you can add this to the mountain of books on Welles and make a note of its intriguing details.

Orson Welles rehearsing War of the Worlds broadcast, 1938.

Orson Welles, given such a vast and complex career, continues to inspire great love and hate. Hazelgrove comes out of the gate exhibiting his scorn like a badge of honor with a bombastic description of what it must have been like for Orson Welles, someone wielding so much power as a star of the dazzling new medium of radio. No doubt, numerous casual listeners to a radio play of H.G. Wells’s The War of the Worlds, adapted to sound like a realistic news broadcast, were innocently caught unawares in 1938 and this resulted in a panic. Hazelgrove turns the screws with his suggestion that Welles should have known better and that a touch of evil must have been at play that night. Now, whether there is more or less truth to this analysis, Hazelgrove sounds very certain. However, keep in mind, that is just Hazelgrove’s suggestion. Smithsonian Magazine presents a case of Welles and his Mercury Players team scrambling to turn their adaptation into something palatable: “The elements of the show that a fraction of its audience found so convincing crept in almost accidentally, as the Mercury desperately tried to avoid being laughed off the air.”

Orson on Mars, sketch by Orson Welles, 1938.

Given that Hazelgrove clearly falls within the anti-Welles contingent, it becomes all the more interesting to continue to read onward as he paints as unfavorable a picture of Welles as he can muster. His next target is the Welles masterpiece, Citizen Kane, which Hazelgrove quickly dismisses as a “famous flop.” In Hazelgrove’s opinion, and this is only his opinion being quoted here: “Undoubtedly, people in 1941 left the theater scratching their heads. Some caught it. Most didn’t.” The popular belief is that Citizen Kane was misunderstood in its own time but that is, in fact, not the case. There are so many facts to work with that can be spun in so many directions. William Randolph Hearst got in the way of Citizen Kane succeeding at the box office but, without a doubt, Citizen Kane, in its own time, was a critical success. So, herein lies the frustration, and fun, in discussing Welles and his work. There is more than enough room to spin the facts and tilt your argument in one direction or another. All in all, Hazelgrove offers up an engaging and highly readable addition to Welles scholarship. I don’t have to completely believe him or agree with him and you don’t have to either but, like Orson Welles himself, Hazelgrove offers something lively and highly relevant for further discussion.

2 Comments

Filed under Book Reviews, Orson Welles

The Apprentice: An American Horror Story movie review

The Apprentice: An American Horror Story. Director: Ali Abbasi. Writer: Gabriel Sherman. Starring Sebastian Stan. Jeremy Strong. Maria Bakalova. 2024.

Even the most loyal fan of Donald Trump will likely find something to appreciate from the Trump biopic, The Apprentice: An American Horror Story, which, by no small measure, is like what Citizen Kane was for William Randolph Hearst. The Trump film is not attempting anything as grandiose as redefining filmmaking but, while Trump’s lawyers would argue otherwise, it can hardly be dismissed as a “hit job.” No, this film is significant. As a story of one person’s descent into the abyss, it is impossible to resist the pull of this film. While it may seem, at first, to be merely framed within the confines of a biopic, it has a certain grace and gravitas all its own, with a distinctive degree of horror. I’ll demonstrate with a series of storyboards I created on the fly while viewing and later refined a bit.

And, one day, this will be Trump Tower!

The opening shots set the tone for an ambitious film with a young Donald Trump, circa 1974, the big player center stage. He is gallivanting through the decay and despair of economically throttled New York City. His eye is on the eyesore of the once opulent Commodore Hotel, the long dead crown jewel of a bygone Grand Central Terminal super-block. The young Don sees a way back to the glory days but that story is yet to unfold, a quintessential example of graft in the extreme.

Hi, I’m Donald Trump.

Steadily, we reach the core theme with the first meeting of young Don and the infamous take-no-prisoners super lawyer Roy Cohn. Early on, Cohn is impressed that Donald has managed to schmooze his way into membership to the same elite club he belongs to. He sees potential in the handsome bumbler.

Rules of the Game.

As his mentor, Cohn teaches the Donald the rules of the game, if you want to win at any cost: Rule 1: Attack, Attack Attack; Rule 2: Admit Nothing, Deny Everything; and Rule 3: Claim Victory, Never Admit Defeat.

Dinner with the Trumps.

So much of the raw content that makes up this film is bits of facts we’ve heard before but the film manages to look at them from a different angle as during a family dinner scene. There’s the patriarch, Fred Trump, openly belittling the eldest son, Fred Jr., for never having amounted to anything important. Fred Trump does not come across as an over-the-top villain, just a miserable person. There’s a deadening acceptance by everyone at the table that Freddy is a failure, not up to Trump standards. It is one of the most sorrowful Trump family facts that is a recurring motif.

It was love that didn’t stand a chance.

Why can’t Fred Jr. find his place in the world or why is it that the Trump family can’t seem to find a way to make him feel welcome? The answer is that Freddy doesn’t have the killer instinct. But Donald does–and that makes all the difference in the world.

No love to spare.

Again, at its core, this is a film about Donald and Roy Cohn. It turns out that the sorcerer’s apprentice has learned his lessons all too well. The tone of the characters drops from dark to darker and even pitch black at times. We see Don out to win at all costs. There’s a good amount of time spent depicting Donald stalking Ivana before he made her his bride, only to later assault her and discard her. Given enough time, Don will even discard his beloved mentor, Roy Cohn.

Young Donald Trump.

 

Of course, the film is self-conscious of its subject, its relevance and its undeniable connection to Citizen Kane. There’s a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment with the young Don in his bachelor pad viewing Nixon on TV while in the background there’s a big movie poster of Citizen Kane.

Trump’s Rosebud.

 

The final frames of the film zoom in on Trump, now a full-fledged killer in the game of life. And, just like a fanciful scene from Citizen Kane, the camera closes in on his eyeball, an American flag waving from within. While not a perfect match, the Citizen Kane/The Apprentice comparison is definitely worth discussion. It’s interesting for me to discover, having lately been reading up on Orson Welles, that there was a growing consensus by critics, when Citizen Kane was released in 1941, that somehow that film failed to capture something. When you tallied it all up, Charles Foster Kane remained an enigma and perhaps not someone even worthy of so much attention. Well, from today’s point of view, that uncanny hollowness makes the film all the more alluring. Also, from today’s point of view, it should give us all quite a shudder.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics

William Shatner: You Can Call Me Bill movie review

You Can Call Me Bill. Legion M. written and directed by Alexandre O. Philippe. 2024.

Pop culture documentary filmmaker Alexandre O. Philippe directs but, I suspect, William Shatner leads, even commands the scene, in this new film about his life and times. It could really be no other way. As the saying goes, any actor worth his salt can recite the phone book and turn it into compelling entertainment. That, indeed, is what Shatner is all about. Right from the start, it is Shatner who is the boss as he hits the ground running, speaking in awe about the wonders of the world around him, alternating between hushed tones and a booming voice.

William Shatner in the graphic novel, George’s Run.

I know a thing or two about pop culture myself and I can tell you that, as many times as you’ve seen William Shatner (easily one of the most filmed persons in human history), you haven’t seen him quite like this and I mean the cumulative result you get in this documentary from hearing him out as he masterfully, even miraculously, never loses the thread to some of his more ambitious dramatic leaps of faith. The documentary does a great job of seamlessly alternating between interview segments with Shatner in the present and classic clips from his career. There’s one priceless clip, for example, where Shatner is given the stage at the Golden Globes in order to set up the next segment, some sort of lifetime achievement award to George Lucas. Shatner, at first, appears to be genuinely befuddled as to whether or not he’s at some Star Trek event. There’s a quick cut over to George Lucas who looks perplexed and not at all amused. And then, presto, Shatner reveals a prop at just the right moment: a piece of paper, presumably notes he was supposed to have read telling him he’s there to honor Lucas. At just the right moment, the audience is in on the joke and Shatner receives well-earned laughs and applause. And that, in essence, is what this documentary is all about: one segment after another giving way to one clip after another, all in the service of painting a bigger picture of a savvy and hard-working entertainer/sage storyteller. It’s the stuff of legend and, heck, totally transcends any mere pop culture theme. This is the story of someone who must live life large, who came of age in an era that celebrated such a journey, and who has never stopped.

Excerpt from GEORGE’S RUN.

In my graphic novel, George’s Run, published by Rutgers University Press, I recount in various ways the golden age of television that gave us such gems as the original Twilight Zone and Star Trek. I don’t just give you a few examples of some beloved moments from these shows but provide context regarding the key players, primarily the writers but also the actors (particularly William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy) who helped to fuel and build the evolving creative sparks into so much more.

This doc sets Shatner loose to be himself, and, in doing so, provides a great service. In somewhat similar fashion, Leonard Nimoy got his chance to set the record straight in 2016’s For The Love of Spock, directed by his son, Adam Nimoy. If you happen to see both, you’ll get what amounts to one of the best tributes to both of these actors who, by their own grit and high level of integrity did much to secure the course and fate of the USS Enterprise.

5 Comments

Filed under Comics, Movie Reviews, Star Trek