Tag Archives: Socialism

If I Could But See It: A Graphic Biography of William Morris comics review

If I Could But See It: A Graphic Biography of William Morris. Nick Thorkelson. Ed. Paul Buhle and Mari Jo Buhle. Pluto Press. 126pp. $25.76.

William Morris . . . equate him with a bundle of energy, on the move, hungering for a new challenge. A person who took the liberal arts ethos to heart. Born 1834. Died 1896. His doctor famously said of Morris dying at a relatively young age: “William Morris died from being William Morris. He lived ten lives in his time.” Just like so many young people before him and after him, he dearly wanted to make his mark and to help make this a better world for all of us. All of his activity informed his work as a textile designer, poet and activist. All of his activity was fueled by revolutionary socialist and anti-capitalist passions to oppose industrialization and make authentic hand-made art to be shared with the masses. During a lively discussion on a worker revolt, a full scale revolution, Morris famously said, “If I could but see a day of it. If I could but see it!” Thus the title to this graphic biography by acclaimed cartoonist Nick Thorkelson. It requires a great passion, bordering on obsession, to do a graphic biography properly–and this Thorkelson has done.

William Morris (1834 – 1896)

Does the young student hear the siren song of William Morris as loud and clear as generations past? No, it’s a different playing field. Any young person will tell you that, if they don’t know something, it’s besides the point since they can get an instant summation by a quick tap and scroll. Aside from that, it is inevitable that William Morris will make contact with every new crop of freshmen at least in the same manner as academia’s delivery of Plato’s cave and Beowulf. But is that good enough? No, it’s not. That’s where a graphic biography like this can step in and bring home what is engaging, exciting and relevant about William Morris and related matters. A.I. will not suffice! You need a cartoonist with ferocity, that unique human touch, to light up the page. Thorkelson, a true cartoonist down to his bones, employs a variety of visual delights to keep the narrative flowing and secure that the information presented is clear and concise. As you can see in the example below, depicting a creative discussion/debate, William Morris and a colleague literally dive from one panel to the next during their lively exchange.

If you’re newly invested in the liberal arts, why wouldn’t you want to get acquainted with one of the greatest polymaths ever known? I recall, in my youth, having a quick appreciation for Morris. I connected him with the Pre-Raphaelite movement in the arts, circa mid-1800s, having to do with a return to a more earthy approach prior to academic painter, Raphael. Indeed, it was a vision intertwined with the whimsical, pastoral, humane and so much more; nothing less than seeking the meaning of life! A noble mindset that Morris and his friends fed upon. Young people of his day worshiped painters and poets in the same way that pop stars and influencers are today but at a decidedly profound level. Thorkelson does a great job of evoking that sense of wonder.

And then it’s all about the follow-through, and Morris and his college coterie were well up to the challenge. That was the whole point. As young people from another generation would be inspired to start up a band, Morris and his group wanted to tap into a way to bring art back to the people and, remarkably, they would settle upon forming an arts and craft design firm specializing in affordable decorative domestic items, focusing on furniture and textile designs. This being a profoundly art-friendly group, it is something of a miracle that they were to become such a successful business, catching the attention of everyone, including Queen Victoria. And therein lay the rub. As well as the group did, particularly with rich clients, it could not help but conflict with their natural alliance with the poor and working class. Victorian capitalism was on shaky ground: the new era of industrialization exploited the working class; the two-party system appeared to be utterly bankrupt. The British Socialist movement was on the rise. This inspired William Morris, who would go on to contribute significantly not only to art, design and poetry, but also maintain a lifelong role as an activist.

Furnishing fabric; – Strawberry Thief; cotton; indigo discharge and block print; by William Morris (1834 – 96); English; 1883.

William Morris . . . equate him with a bundle of energy, on the move, hungering for a new challenge–and fighting for a solution to the poor being subjugated by the rich. If you hunger for a better world, one that brings people first, then William Morris is an excellent entry point. Nick Thorkelson makes the case so very well. We live in such a hectic and fragmented time but pause we must, contemplate we must–protest and never give in to an easy fix lest capitalism swallow you whole.

England’s Victorian era, for all its pomp, beneath its surface faced a massive political, economic and cultural rebellion. We see a similar perfect storm in the U.S. A first corrective step is just weeks away with the midterm elections.

Editor’s Note: After the main feature to this book, Sharon Rudahl, an accomplished comic artist and noted member of the Comics Underground, provides a delightful illustrated adaptation of the literary works of William Morris. Many thanks also must go to this book’s editors, Paul Buhle and Mari Jo Buhle, who provide an insightful and highly informative Afterword.

Leave a comment

Filed under Comics, Comics Reviews

Paul Buhle on Comics: ‘Mutual Aid: an Illuminated Factor of Evolution’

Mutual Aid: an Illuminated Factor of Evolution. By Peter Kropotkin, illustrated by N.O. Bonzo, with an Introduction by David Graeber and Andrej Grubacic. PM Press, 317pp. $20.00

Guest Review by Paul Buhle

This large and beautiful book is so much like a comic that it cannot be described effectively in any other way. “Illustrated text” would not convey, especially for the younger readers of graphic novels, what has been accomplished here, and especially because 21st century readers “see” the pages differently from their predecessors and perhaps closer to ways that children have always “seen” favorite books—or at least the ways this reviewer saw them, literally learning to read by reading comics.

That said, we come immediately to David Graeber himself as a 21st century comet, rising into the sky and sinking again with his sudden, untimely death in 2021. His final text, an extended exploration of archeological history seeking the presence of largely peaceful, pre-state societies, has not convinced all readers by a long shot, but made his political points effectively. Class society seems to have been a fairly recent experience for Homo Sapiens, and its supremacy does not seem to have come from superior production of needed goods or any variant, such as organized agriculture. Yugoslavian-born Andrj Grabacic, a past collaborator with Staughton Lynd, obviously brings his own anarchistic fashion of political analysis into the mix.

Kropotkin, the Russian aristocrat, had a lot in common with other 19th century reformers including Marx: society, they believed, could be transformed by better, more scientific information and application. We had not yet entered the 20th century, where war became the decisive factor “for the West” that it had already been for the colonized world since the 17th century, at least. The choices for human society appeared to be more open and more peaceful until the First World War smashed so many illusions.

Mutual Aid, with its splendid subtitle, argues that society engages in communal relations at all times, making “capitalism” and “nationalism” the intruders. Marx saw the new society within the old in the sphere of socialized labor, no matter how brutal and alienated. Kropotkin looked outward.

The charm of this reprint, with splendid art, begins for today with the prince’s insistence upon “mutual aid among animals,” a powerful argument for its time, but more likely to be recognized now. Kropotkin insists, for instance, that a greedy sparrow seeking to monopolize nesting areas will be stopped by the flock. Contrary examples can certainly be found, but from scientific discoveries of “mother trees” to closer examination of interspecies collaboration, it seems science may be catching up with the prince who famously resigned his title.

Of course, Kropotkin’s main subject is human society, and if his arguments are somewhat familiar, the drawings of Bonzo are startling. I do not even recognize the name of this postmodern, feminist artisan, who lives in Portland and helped to create the Antifascist Coloring Book. Whatever the case, this is the closest to a reanimation of Williams Morris’s visions that I have seen in recent times. “Swipes,” in old comic book language, are taken freely from illustrations six generations past, but updated charmingly. We discover for instance with “harm reduction,” widespread enough to become a social movement in itself, that modern-day cooperators are re-learning how to help others through easing their bouts of addiction.

The chapter called “Mutual Aid in the Medieval City” is bound to remain a personal favorite of mine, because here Kropotkin comes so close to Morris, drawing upon similar sources, such as the histories of the guilds. We see the words of the text, and around them the images of working men and women who believed deeply in what they did. We can see cooperation, in other words, in a new light.

Quite a book, quite a revival of Kropotkin.

Paul Buhle

2 Comments

Filed under Comics, Comics Reviews, Paul Buhle

Review: ‘Pinko Joe: A New Kind of Graphic Novel’ by Christopher Sperandio

Pinko Joe: A New Kind of Graphic Novel

Pinko Joe: A New Kind of Graphic Novel. Christopher Sperandio. Argle Bargle Books. 2020. 96pp. $21.99

Artist Christopher Sperandio is onto something. As he related to us in a recent interview, it dawned on him what he could do with public domain comics and it just killed him that he hadn’t thought of it sooner. As reviewed here at Comics Grinder, the latest book in this series is Greenie Josephinie. We are going to go back just a bit and focus on the title that kicked it all off last year, Pinko Joe.

Enter a man in a bright pink suit.

Due to the pandemic, I think this series, like so many titles, is still getting on reader’s radars. But this is not a problem in the long run. There’s an eerie timeless quality to this multi-layered work that defies easy categorization. The source material is from the past (shifted and unmoored) in the service of subverting various issues from the present and let loose upon an uncertain and distant future. We see testament to the beauty of this process  from the very opening page, filled with disparate images (featuring a guy in a bright pink suit that David Bowie would have been pleased to wear) from some long forgotten past, images that are being propelled into a loopy present and future. Enter a man in a bright pink suit, nicknamed, “Pinko Joe,” by the merciless right-wing media.

“Capitalism is always evaluated against dreams! Utopia is a dream! It doesn’t exist!”

My theory is that every comics genre gives off a certain vibe, even if the excerpt you are viewing is totally out of context and you can barely figure out what is going on. That is part of the beauty behind what Sperandio is up to since his source material runs the gamut of genres: crime, romance, science fiction and horror. Then you lay on top of that the subversive adventures of Pinko Joe, a down-on-his-luck wage slave/activist from another planet! It becomes a battle royale between the socialists led by Pinko Joe and the uber-capitalist gangsters in an alternate reality where Eisenhower is at the helm of a third term and the rise of the very military-industrial complex he warned about–and which he can dismantle with a little help from his friends!

The wild and droll world of Pinko Joe!

The narrative to this graphic novel is broken up into episodic chunks just as you find in a comic book. While this is definitely a very different kind of graphic novel, and will definitely appeal to a certain discerning reader, the droll political humor is really funny and has broad appeal. Think of the audience for The Daily Show or for Real Time with Bill Maher. Let’s break down a random full page. Based upon the list of sources at the back of the book, this is probably originally a page from a comic book, Crime Must Pay the Penalty, published by Ace Magazines, October 1950. On the page, a dapper young man appears to defend a wealthy family from thugs. In the Sperandio treatment, it is Pinko Joe who is defending a father and daughter business from capitalist gangsters. The dialogue is fun and irreverent. Panel 2 makes a nice stand-alone as Pinko Joe knocks out one of the “fascists.”

“Knuckles for you, fascist!”

There’s a pure vision to what Sperandio is doing and I’m sure it will guide him onwards. Many an artist has come before with a tribute or a revisiting of past art. This tribute and revisiting by Sperandio, a manipulation of comics, and a comic all its own, is something Andy Warhol would have applauded. Maybe Warhol would never have ventured in such a direction himself or maybe he might have hired Sperandio to join him. My guess is that Sperandio would say thanks, but no thanks.

Find PINKO JOE and  GREENIE JOSEPHENIE, along with other fine books, at Argle Bargle Books!

4 Comments

Filed under Argle Bargle Books, Christopher Sperandio, Comics, Graphic Novel Reviews

Review: THE JUNGLE, adapted and illustrated by Kristina Gehrmann

THE JUNGLE, adapted and illustrated by Kristina Gehrmann

You may recall The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair, from high school or college and it having to do with exposing the corruption in the meatpacking industry. Well, it exposed that and much more and remains quite relevant. The Jungle finds a whole new life, and a new way to reach audiences, with the new graphic novel adaptation by Kristina Gehrmann, published by Ten Speed Press, an imprint of Penguin Random House.

This is the story of Jurgis and his fiancée Ona and the Rudkus and Lukozaite families, ten in all. They are bright-eyed Lithuanian imigrants looking forward to a new start in the United States, beginning with their arrival at Ellis Island in 1899. The story only progresses for a few years but much transpires as everyone is in for one rude awakening after another. America may be known as a melting pot and immigrants may have been acknowledged as having helped to make America great. But at what cost to the naive, vulnerable and poor? That question is at the heart of the novel.

A relationship at the breaking point.

The original 1906 novel’s exposé of the dangerous practices in slaughterhouses led to actual reform. However, other issues the novel addresses, such as fair housing, immigration, worker’s rights and sexual assault, would not be so readily addressed at the start of the 20th century. Due to Gehrmann’s compelling adaptation and artwork, the old becomes fresh, open for rediscovery and new discussion. Gehrmann combines a cartoony style with realistic touches, along with a Manga-like energy that keeps the narrative moving at a contemporary pace. The reader immediately relates with Jurgis and Ona, a struggling young couple trying to prosper but often just barely surviving. It gradually becomes a relationship at the breaking point. In the Sinclair novel, that was drama to keep a book with a socialist message moving along but, in the graphic novel, it is given an added dimension that will appeal to today’s reader.

The original novel by Upton Sinclair remains a powerful rebuke of those in power who would prey upon the weak. Kristina Gehrmann’s graphic novel adaptation provides an essential gateway to the revered classic and is a remarkable work in its own right. Disillusioned with the novel’s impact, Upton Sinclair famously said, “I aimed at the public’s heart, and by accident hit it in the stomach.” This graphic novel helps to bring out to new readers the greater socialist themes found in Upton Sinclair’s original novel. This is a high accessible work that retains the power of the original novel while inviting a contemporary eye.

The Jungle, the new adaptation by Kristina Gehrmann, is a 384-page trade paperback, fully illustrated duotone graphic novel, published by Ten Speed Press, an imprint of Penguin Random House.

2 Comments

Filed under Comics, Graphic Novel Reviews, Social Justice, Socialism

Interview: Nick Thorkelson and HERBERT MARCUSE: PHILOSOPHER OF UTOPIA

Herbert Marcuse, Philosopher of Utopia: A Graphic Biography

Herbert Marcuse is not a household name in the same way today as, say, Marshall McLuhan, another intellectual who broke into mainstream consciousness. However, Marcuse was a huge focal point for many protesters during the sixties and his ideas have great relevance for today’s challenging times. I say this as a way to cast as wide a net as possible for potential readers of a very compelling new work in the comics medium, Herbert Marcuse, Philosopher of Utopia: A Graphic Biography, co-authored and drawn by Nick Thorkelson, edited by Paul Buhle and Andrew T. Lamas, published by City Lights. It was my pleasure to get a chance to interview Mr. Thorkelson.

Herbert Marcuse, a hero of the student protest movement.

Marxism. Socialism. Capitalism. Philosophy. All of this does not add up to light and casual reading. However, a concise grinding through the comics medium can result in something quite enlightening–and here Nick Thorkelson succeeds to unpack issues with just the right touch. If you are at all interested in the politics and philosophy behind the tumultuous times we live in, then you will appreciate diving into this graphic biography. We cover in this interview just enough to give you a sense of the subject at hand. There’s the pesky sound of a leaf blower that momentarily vies for attention but it just goes to show that life is forever moving forward which is rather apropos to the spirit of our chat. Without a doubt, we live in dangerous and troubling times but, by learning from the past, it informs and inspires our present and our future. If you are not satisfied with the status quo, and dream of a better future, then you’ll want to read this essential guide to Herbert Marcuse.

Herbert Marcuse, Philosopher of Utopia is a 128-page trade paperback in duotone, available now, published by City Lights.

3 Comments

Filed under AOC, Bernie Sanders, City Lights Publishers, Comics, Donald Trump, Frankfurt School, Graphic Biography, graphic novels, Herbert Marcuse, Martin Heidegger, Nazi Germany, Nick Thorkelson, Socialism, Socialists